17 North Beach Street
Nantucket, MA 02554
(508) 228-1515
What's Inn?
The new faces of Nantucket's historic hotels
Written by David Creed
The days of the four-poster bed, laced curtains, and braided rugs as the décor de jour for inns on Nantucket have long been a thing of the past. Dowdy has been supplanted with cool with respect to the interiors of the island’s newest inns and hotels. Frumpy has been replaced by luxury with thousand-count sheets, designer toiletries, and gourmet breakfast offerings. The following is a summary of newly designed or renovated hotels for this season that are raising the bar of hotel offerings on the island. More than simply inns, these are places to truly stay in.
76 Main Ink Press Hotel
In-Season Pricing: $649-$1,049
The only hotel on Main Street, 76 Main, has gone through a total redesign that combines a coastal aesthetic with a captivating theme of media on the island. Rebranded as the 76 Main Ink Press Hotel, the walls in the common areas, lobby, and rooms have become a means to tell stories about Nantucket over the last 200 years as seen through the eyes of Nantucket’s print and broadcast media. Everywhere you look, the hotel reveals some part of Nantucket’s history.
Each room has its own story theme, ranging from famous journalists on the island to broadcast media personalities to stories of shipwrecks and those of the whaling days. Certain rooms focus on famous island personalities, including beloved author Elin Hilderbrand, whose bestselling book
The Perfect Couple is about to become a Netflix feature series.
The Beachside by Blue Flag Capital
In-Season Price Range: $549-$1,349
The Beachside has transformed from a modest motel into a luxurious retreat, capturing Nantucket’s summer traditions. This 92-room hotel is perfect for families, with adult and kids pools, Barnaby’s Kids Club, and an arcade. Guests can enjoy summer classics at the Swim Club or take advantage of on-site yoga and Peloton bikes in the gym.
Evenings come to life with Dreamland’s outdoor movie nights under the stars. Described as “a love note to a Great American summer,” The Beachside offers a family-friendly alternative, previously exclusive to the Nantucket Hotel on Easton Street. Enjoy exclusive dining without reservations, featuring fresh island fare, local snacks, and creamsicles.
The Swim Club’s poolside service and takeaway menus cater to all ages. Cool off at the Lobby Bar & Lounge or explore local provisions, picnic wine, and stylish cabana shirts at the on-site shop. Whether exploring on complimentary bikes or relaxing in serene spots, every detail at The Beachside ensures a memorable stay.
19 Broad/Swain House
In-Season Price Range: $849-$1,249
Adjacent to the hotel known as 21 Broad, 19 Broad/Swain House was built in the late 1800s by coal merchant Andrew Hunt, who originally owned both properties with his brother-in-law Captain William Swain. This Victorian masterpiece, used primarily as a private residence, now offers the unique distinction of being available to rent by the room or the entire house, making it stand out under new short-term rental laws. Fully renovated with a contemporary, minimalist vibe, the hotel shares a large, private deck with its neighbor, 21 Broad.
21 Broad, previously known as the Nesbitt Inn, is the longest continually running hotel on Nantucket. Constructed in 1878 by Charles Robinson, Nantucket’s most prolific builder of the late 19th century, 19 Broad is one of the finest examples of Victorian architecture remaining on Nantucket. It retains many of its character-defining features, including ornamental carvings by James W. Folger. The Swain House stands as proof of the enduring appeal of Victorian design, offering a glimpse into the island’s rich architectural heritage.
The Brant (Salt House)
In-Season Price Range: $695-$1,040
The Brant, a luxurious renovation of the former Dolphin Hotel on North Beach Street, is now a high-end inn and mini resort. Featuring rooms with kitchenettes and a breezy coastal feel, The Brant offers an exclusive equity membership program, which provides guests with access to dedicated rooms each year, The Brant’s Jeeps, dedicated storage space, and concierge services. Members also enjoy access to an exclusive lounge, partnered with Veuve Clicquot, adding a touch of luxury to their stay.
The Martin
In-Season Price Range: $600-$1,400
The Martin has been newly renovated and redesigned by Nantucket Looms. Its former traditional aesthetic has been reimagined with a coastal theme, featuring varied hues of gray, green, and blue, giving it a distinctly contemporary feel. Built in 1803, The Martin has 15 rooms, provides a complimentary continental breakfast, and is open year-round.
Latest Stories
